How to Lose Business by Gold Plating

How to lose business
How to lose business by gold plating

I worked my way through college waiting tables.  At one place I worked, we had a cook who treated employee meals differently than customer meals.  Customers received the standard fair.  They got what they ordered.  But when an employee went on break and ordered a meal, this cook had a tendency to “gold plate” it.  If you ordered a cheeseburger, you were likely to get double-bacon cheeseburger.  Side of fries? You would get a big honkin basket of fries.

It was a nice gesture, but we would often get much more than we could eat. Sometimes we would get something we didn’t even want. We could see that he was trying hard to get in good with his fellow staff members. But he was trying a little too hard. It was overkill.

I’ve seen the same thing in consulting. Perhaps a company sends out a request for proposal for a simple website to process orders.  The consulting firm is competing with two others for the business. In their competitive drive to win the business, they over-engineer the solution, over-solve the problem, and end up proposing a trumped-up solution that the prospect didn’t want.

When the consulting firm loses a proposal like this, they go through various stages of denial.  First, they assume they lost on price.  They’ll ask the prospect if they looked closely at the functionality they included.  They want them to understand that the high cost is reflected in the fact that they included more stuff. The prospective client probably understood that.

Then, the firm assumes that the prospective client didn’t understand the solution they proposed.  Because if they did, they would certainly have continued the dialog. Chances are the client understood the solution. It just wasn’t the solution they asked for, that they wanted, or that they were going to buy.

Gold plating happens once the client wins the business too.  In the software development consulting world in which I work, we contract with clients to write web software.  The scope of the project is defined around a certain set of parameters. Project managers need to monitor the work by the team members to make sure their work falls within those parameters.

See my related post: Consulting Priority: Billable Hours

Computer programmers, like many good workers, can have a tendency to get excited.  Writing code strictly within functional requirements gets boring after a while.  So why not make it a little fancier? Instead of having all these selection boxes as prescribed, they might create a drop down window option.  The users will certainly love that better.

When that happens, it’s well outside of the client’s expectations. Not only does the developer spend extra time doing work that wasn’t asked for, they spend more time reversing it after the user rejects it.

Going over and above the call of duty is admirable. But when consultants go too far, creating value that’s not valuable, they create the nuclear flyswatter that is not wanted, not needed and most likely, won’t be paid for.

If you would like to learn more about working in consulting, get Lew’s book Consulting 101: 101 Tips for Success in Consulting at Amazon.com

As always, I welcome your comments and criticisms. 

Related Posts
Who sells consulting services?
Early in my career, I worked for a large consulting firm that evaluated their employees on five criteria: Knowledge: How much has the employee learned over the evaluation period? Service: How well ...
READ MORE
The Difficult Client Types
I've worked in very few organizations that didn’t have a jerk or two walking around.  Over the years I’ve learned to deal with them. In the one situation where the jerk was ...
READ MORE
Consulting Skill: Know the Client’s Business
Over the years, I’ve seen various levels of client satisfaction with their consultants.  Some consultants make themselves so indispensable that the client tries to hire them as a full-time employee.  ...
READ MORE
Follow Through – Just Go To Benson
I grew up attending a small school district which was the consolidation of two small towns.  What is nowadays called middle school was called junior high school back then.  The ...
READ MORE
The Aloof Consultant
I once had a new consultant join my team who entered the client site as if he owned the place.  He was expected to share a cubicle with a fellow ...
READ MORE
The Arsonist and the Fireman
The City’s Hero The city was experiencing a rash of fires.  Arson was usually suspected but the source of the flame could never be proven. Fortunately, the city had a crack firefighting ...
READ MORE
Do You Deliver a Transparent Status Report?
I once managed a project for a multi-site organization to implement software at each location. I held a weekly status conference-call with the company’s executives which included the branch manager from ...
READ MORE
How Important Is Client Facetime?
“Papa was a rollin’ stone.  Wherever he laid his hat was his home.”            - The Temptations I have a friend who works for a major technology company in the U.S.  He ...
READ MORE
Are You Keeping a Client Focus?
In an episode of ‘House of Lies’, the Showtime series loosely based on management consulting, there was a situation where the team was tasked with reviewing a pharmaceutical client’s internal ...
READ MORE
Is Consulting Worth It?
My daughter is a junior in high school and in the process of investigating colleges.  In a parallel effort, I’m in the process of investigating how to maximize her ability ...
READ MORE
Who sells consulting services?
The Difficult Client Types
Consulting Skill: Know the Client’s Business
Follow Through – Just Go To Benson
The Aloof Consultant
The Arsonist and the Fireman
Do You Deliver a Transparent Status Report?
How Important Is Client Facetime?
Are You Keeping a Client Focus?
Is Consulting Worth It?