Playgrounds, Checklists and Making Things Idiot Proof

idiot proof
Playgrounds, Checklists and Making Things Idiot Proof

An article in the New York Times from July of 2011 entitled “Can a Playground Be Too Safe?” discusses the trend over the past few decades of making playgrounds safer.  By reducing the height of sliding boards and monkey bars and replacing the old pavement with rubberized or softer surfaces, it stands to reason that we’ve made the environments safer, right?

Safer playgrounds?

Not necessarily.   Some studies have shown that it has not reduced the number of injuries.  Because we’ve made playgrounds so safe, children feel a false sense of security with the improved safety.  They are more willing to take bigger safety risks and end up injuring themselves just as often.

In the business world, we talk a lot about processes.  We particularly like to design repeatable processes.  If we can standardize processes to the point of being idiot proof, we hope to create an efficient workforce with consistent output.

Is idiot proof good?

It all sounds great theoretically.

But what do you do when non-standard things occur in the middle of these standard processes.  Sometimes processes are established with flexibility to deal with these situations.  Sometimes it has to be escalated to a senior manager for decision making, delaying the standard process that was designed to be so streamlined.

It’s been said that if you make something idiot-proof, they’ll just create a better idiot.

Consultants are known for implementing “process improvements” that make their clients more efficient and run leaner.  They are successful in many cases.  Software applications can be built that reduce the number of manual tasks, enabling companies to process more information faster.  Even well-designed processes can make a team work faster and more efficient.

See my related post: Good Manager, Poor Leader. What’s Missing?

But designing processes without allowing people the ability to think, make decisions and call an audible when exceptions occur is a dual waste of time.  Time is wasted designing the system and time is wasted following the flawed process and figuring out what to do for exceptions.

Fundamentally, if you make a complex process so easy that a moron can do it, you’ll end up with a staff of morons.

If you would like to learn more about working in consulting, get Lew’s book Consulting 101: 101 Tips for Success in Consulting at Amazon.com

As always, I welcome your comments and criticisms. 

Related Posts
What I’ve Learned From Leadership Analysis
My kids sometimes come home from school frustrated by someone who didn’t treat them well or maybe just acted like a selfish jerk. I’ve tried to teach them that people ...
READ MORE
Motivation: Positive and Negative Incentives
When I was in high school, I had a fantastic U.S. History teacher.  He had us subscribe to Time Magazine and we were required to read an editorial from the ...
READ MORE
Consulting Skill: Getting Others to Communicate
  One of the most critical consulting skills is communication.  A good consultant needs to know when to communicate, when not to, and the most effective way to do it when ...
READ MORE
Accountability vs Blame
  Everyone makes a mistake on occasion.  I’ve seen the smartest and most meticulous people write down the wrong time or date for a meeting.  It happens.  And as long as ...
READ MORE
Performance Evaluations – Carrot  or Stick?
At some point in each year companies finish up their annual performance evaluations.  It can be a bittersweet time.  You get to receive some frank feedback from your boss, while being ...
READ MORE
Boundless optimism: We Need 16 to Tie, 17 for the Lead
My son had a baseball tournament this past weekend at a park complex that had multiple fields.  While we waited for another game to finish so that his team could play, ...
READ MORE
Is It Bad To Be a Bossy Woman?
There has been a lot of talk about bossy women lately.  Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg is leading a formidable group of successful women, including Condoleezza Rice and Girl Scouts CEO ...
READ MORE
A Mentoring Role Reversal
Most of us have had some exposure to a mentoring program.  Many companies implement programs at various levels of formality and to various levels of success. Some organizations establish formal policies ...
READ MORE
Are You Purchasing Effective Tools?
I’m pretty handy around the house.  My workshop has a decent supply of tools and I can fix and maintain most of the issues that occur in my home. If something ...
READ MORE
Contrasting Middle-School Management Styles
Like millions of kids out there, my son is just winding down the school year.  He’s a good student but also a free spirit and sometimes goes beyond his limits ...
READ MORE
What I’ve Learned From Leadership Analysis
Motivation: Positive and Negative Incentives
Consulting Skill: Getting Others to Communicate
Accountability vs Blame
Performance Evaluations – Carrot or Stick?
Boundless optimism: We Need 16 to Tie, 17
Is It Bad To Be a Bossy Woman?
A Mentoring Role Reversal
Are You Purchasing Effective Tools?
Contrasting Middle-School Management Styles