What if Your Plumber Gave You “IT” Customer Service?

customer service
Would you put up with poor customer service from your plumber?

Imagine a scenario where you have a pipe that leaks under your kitchen sink.  You may be an expert user of water and all things plumbing, but when it comes to the technical solution of fixing a leak, you know enough to turn to the experts.

So you call a plumber who comes to your house to investigate.  You show him the leak and tell him, “That pipe right there needs to be replaced.  How much will you charge to replace it?”

The plumber, by virtue of his title, knows a little more about plumbing than you do. He investigates the leak and determines that, in addition to the pipe you have pointed out, there is another pipe that needs replacing.


The plumber has 3 customer service options:

  • Follow your orders.  You want this pipe replaced.  So he’ll do exactly as he’s told.  The customer is always right.  Why make waves and tell you that you’re wrong?
  • Tell you you’re wrong. Say something like “I’m the professional here and you don’t know what the hell you’re talking about.” That will put you in your place and teach you a few things about telling him how to do his job.
  • Advise you. He could just say, “You’re right, that pipe does need to be replaced.  Something else I also notice is that there is a problem with this other pipe.  It would be a good solution to replace both of them to prevent this from happening again.”

The first option will please you for the short term.  The plumber is doing exactly what you asked him to do. But sometime down the road, there will be a problem again.  You might call that plumber back.  You might call another one. But you’ll be calling someone for help again.

Option two may address the technical problem correctly.  But no matter how well he solves that technical problem, your customer satisfaction is going to be low.

See my related post: Developing Trust With Conflicting Priorities

The final option is just right. The plumber solves the problem correctly. And while he corrected your suggested solution, he did it diplomatically by mentoring and coaching you. And he did not do it in a condescending way to make you feel stupid.

What customer service do you get from IT?

How does your Information Technology group approach similar situations?  When a user calls for support and tries to suggest what the problem is, do you simply do what they say without providing any analysis into the solution?

Or do you put them in their place by proving them wrong…with a little arrogance and condescension thrown in for good measure?

For more information, see Client Relations for Consultants

Most of my blogs and podcasts are focused on consultants and the need to provide good customer service to their clients. But a good IT organization should strive to be a consulting group for their own company.

Instead of replying reactively to customer issues and simply fulfilling orders, when an issue arises, spend the time to investigate it.  Analyze it and determine the root cause. It may take a little longer to resolve their issue, but they’re less likely to have additional issues further down the road.  And you will have time in the future to deal with other issues instead of solving the same problem over and over.

By becoming their mentor, the IT group could eventually become trusted advisors to the business. You might even get the recognition and respect that you’ve always thought you deserved.

If you would like to learn more about working in consulting, get Lew’s book Consulting 101: 101 Tips for Success in Consulting at Amazon.com

As always, I welcome your comments and criticisms. 

Related Posts
Consulting Skill: Aligning Interests with the Client
In Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner’s best-selling book Freakonomics, they propose a scenario in which you are selling your house with an asking price of $300,000 and receive an offer ...
READ MORE
Some Consulting What Ifs
What if Consultants… Focused on client issues rather than margin and billable hours Acted as if they were guests at a client site – not subservient, but not condescending Said no to the ...
READ MORE
Unnecessary Anxiety
During the late 1990s, then Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan coined the term Irrational Exuberance to denote the absurdity of over-enthusiasm investors had regarding stocks – particularly dot-com stocks – ...
READ MORE
Is Consulting Worth It?
My daughter is a junior in high school and in the process of investigating colleges.  In a parallel effort, I’m in the process of investigating how to maximize her ability ...
READ MORE
Client Focus: Telling Him He Has No Clothes
  As you may know, the folk tale The Emperor's New Clothes by Hans Christian Andersen is the story of two dishonest weavers who convince an emperor that they can make ...
READ MORE
Client Expectation Management
When a client hires a consulting firm, whether it’s a single independent consultant or a full project team from a large firm, they know they are paying a high billing ...
READ MORE
How to Lose Business by Gold Plating
I worked my way through college waiting tables.  At one place I worked, we had a cook who treated employee meals differently than customer meals.  Customers received the standard fair.  ...
READ MORE
Staffing The Right People
Like most things, coordination is critical in consulting.  Consider the following scenarios: Great news Cindy!  We’ve landed the Johnson account.  We start Monday and we want to hit the ground running.  ...
READ MORE
Pushing Too Hard and the Monkey’s Dilemma
Have you ever worked so hard that you didn’t get anything done? The elusive banana The monkey’s dilemma is a well known story about how hunters figured out a way to capture ...
READ MORE
Consulting Skill: Know the Client’s Business
Over the years, I’ve seen various levels of client satisfaction with their consultants.  Some consultants make themselves so indispensable that the client tries to hire them as a full-time employee.  ...
READ MORE
Consulting Skill: Aligning Interests with the Client
Some Consulting What Ifs
Unnecessary Anxiety
Is Consulting Worth It?
Client Focus: Telling Him He Has No Clothes
Client Expectation Management
How to Lose Business by Gold Plating
Staffing The Right People
Pushing Too Hard and the Monkey’s Dilemma
Consulting Skill: Know the Client’s Business