Should I Join a Large Consulting Firm or a Boutique?

large consulting firm
Should I join a large consulting firm?

When I was in my last semester of college, I had interviewed with a lot of different companies and it all came down to three offers to decide among.  One was from an insurance company in central Illinois near my family where I grew up.  Another was from an insurance company in the Chicago area and still another from a small consulting firm, also in the Chicago area.

Consulting or not?

Each one had unique opportunities and it was a difficult decision.  I decided to talk it over with my parents one evening.  I sat down with them and described each offer and what interested me in each offer.

They listened to me and agreed that each one sounded interesting.  I’m sure that they could have been very selfish and steered me toward the offer that was close to home, but they gave me no answers.  They suggested I write down the pros and cons of each on paper to help me come up with a decision.

I left that night with an empty feeling.  Somewhere in the back of my mind I thought they would help me make my decision.  Instead, they made it clear that I needed to make the decision myself.

For more information, check out Getting In to Consulting

Large consulting firm or boutique?

Over the years, I’ve proven to myself over and over that I made the right decision to go into consulting.  I’ve also met people who had similar offers from large consulting firms and from specialized boutique firms.  They weren’t sure which was the right one to join.  Should you work for a large firm, put in 2-3 years to develop some wide-ranging experience and then move on to a firm that specializes in a specific industry?  Or do you go right to the small boutique firm to develop a specialty in your first couple of years, and then move on to a top-tier firm as a subject matter expert in one particular industry or technology?

The answer is that there is no standard formula for that career decision.  Each type of firm – and each individual firm for that matter – has its pros and cons, which vary by individual.  Something that you find interesting in a firm may sound like a prison sentence to someone else.

It’s your decision

After my visit with my parents, I followed the only advice they provided.  I went home and listed the pros and cons of each of my options.  The local insurance company would have allowed me to be close to my family, but it was the lowest paying of the three options.  The insurance company in the Chicago area was the highest paying offer, but I thought working for the same company in the same industry would bore me. Although the consulting firm wasn’t the highest paying offer, I felt it would be the most interesting and would end up paying off in the long run.

See my related post: 5 Things I Hate about Consulting

Each person needs to know enough about each of their options and themselves to decide which one provides the best fit for his or her interests and goals.

Which decision is right for you?

If you would like to learn more about working in consulting, get Lew’s book Consulting 101: 101 Tips for Success in Consulting at Amazon.com

As always, I welcome your comments and criticisms. 

Related Posts
The Consultant’s Private Resume
We’re all familiar with the resume.  A document that “must” be (depending on who you ask) one or two pages.  It’s our primary sales and marketing tool for our career.  We list our ...
READ MORE
Why Consulting Hiring Keeps Rising
As of January, 2013 the U.S. unemployment rate stood at 7.8% (Bureau of Labor Statistics). That’s certainly lower than its peak of 10% in October 2009, but there is still ...
READ MORE
What Do They Mean By Strong Communication Skills?
Published job descriptions are full of ambiguous skill demands.  Demonstrated leadership skills…Flexible, powerful intellect…Creative and curious…Great team player. Those traits are hard to prove; and hard to disprove unless you were ...
READ MORE
The Talent Acquisition Game
Prior to the 1982 baseball season, the Philadelphia Phillies traded their shortstop Larry Bowa to the Chicago Cubs for shortstop Ivan DeJesus.  To sweeten the deal, the Phillies threw in ...
READ MORE
How the Talent Crisis and High Unemployment Co-exist
We continue to hear mixed messages regarding unemployment.  In one month, the Unemployment rate goes down, but it’s because more people gave up and left the market.  Another month it ...
READ MORE
The Proactive Job Search
You’ve probably known people who are in perpetual job-search mode.  As soon as they get a new job, they’re actively looking for their next job.  I’ve known people who don’t ...
READ MORE
5 Reasons College Grads Should Consider a Career in Consulting
While the unemployment rate remains high nationally, most college seniors and MBA students are facing the anxiety and fear of graduating into a work world that doesn’t want them.  According to a ...
READ MORE
Why not consulting?
After a 5-year hiatus from consulting, I recently reentered consulting, joining a Chicago-area consulting firm.  I left consulting because I had never done anything else and wanted to see if ...
READ MORE
When Leaving Your Job Is the Right Option
From the time we start school as a child, our transitions in life are decided for us for many years.  Each year we finish a grade in school, the next ...
READ MORE
5 Job Search Strategies to Differentiate Yourself in the Job Market
As one who has lost his job in each economic downturn that has occurred throughout my career and changed jobs once on my own accord, I’ve been through the painful ...
READ MORE
The Consultant’s Private Resume
Why Consulting Hiring Keeps Rising
What Do They Mean By Strong Communication Skills?
The Talent Acquisition Game
How the Talent Crisis and High Unemployment Co-exist
The Proactive Job Search
5 Reasons College Grads Should Consider a Career
Why not consulting?
When Leaving Your Job Is the Right Option
5 Job Search Strategies to Differentiate Yourself in